Summary of an appeal case Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words

Summary of an appeal case - Essay Example Second, the judge misguided the jury on the issue of consent as it implicated on the present case. Mr. Roberts developed a solution linking the judge’s decision with the fact that he deprived the appellant the Jury’s consideration whether he had a guilty mind or not. However, the sentence on each case was neither excessive nor wrong in principle. While reviewing the case, a number of particulars stand-out based on the case. The case is an aggregation of a number of cases. Although, the facts differ in the three cases, the common details in all the cases include information such as the defendant had an agreed sexual relationship with each woman. Second, all three ladies voluntarily had unprotected sex with the defendant. Third, the appellant did not inform any woman about his HIV status. Finally, all three complainants assumed that the defendant was HIV negative; therefore, exposing themselves to the risk of obtaining a sexually transmitted infection as grievous as HIV virus. Based on the courts judgement, the judge’s guidance to the jury adequately explained the correct implications to the case of the consensual contribution by each complainant’s to sexual intercourse with the appellant. The jury eventually gave the ruling that, in the case of each plaintiff, she did not willingly or cognitively agree to the risk of suffering the HIV virus. Therefore, the court will dismiss the appeal against conviction. The court reviewed its holding in the R v Dica case of informed consent as a defence resulted from limited potential conflicting public policy considerations. In the light of the public interest, the population demands the prevention of the spread of catastrophic illnesses. On the other hand, it also needs that personal freedom in the context of adult non-violent sexual associations need maintenance. By concealing any information about one’s HIV status, the subject denies the

The perspectives of Middle East World to The Crusades and their resist Essay

The perspectives of Middle East World to The Crusades and their resist process - Essay Example For the reason of the resistance, the Muslims started a strong opposing force that was very much objected to the rise of the Christian dominance in the areas of Jerusalem and other cities. In 1095 when the first crusade was held, the Christians focused on the invading the places that they counted important in their history of their religion throughout time. The Muslims in Jerusalem perceived the Christian move as an invasion that was irritating and that needed to be curbed and they raised a force that resisted the impact of the Christian crusaders. When the Christians found that the Muslims had objected to their occupation, they found that they raised a force to advance their occupation and asked for military assistance from their home countries that could help them to conquer the Muslims. On the other hand, the Muslims formed a force that had would help them to oppose the forces of the Christians and reclaim what was almost taken away from them. In the process, there were negative perspective that led to develop an enmity between the two religions within the area and this led to a constant struggle against each other (Claster, 2009). The Muslims perceived the Christians as people who wanted to impose political, economic and social impacts into the culture of the Arabs and the population of the Middle East, which had very different systems in place. The people of Middle East believed that the way the crusaders had influenced the Western Europe could happen to them if they allowed their region to be dominated by the Christians. This made the Muslims to object the move of the Christians to occupy the place they perceived as theirs and made the condition unbearable to them so that the Christians had to devise different ways that occupy the place (Claster, 2009). When some western Christians entered the Middle East, they came as merchants who had a force that threatened the